Skip to main content
SearchLoginLogin or Signup

Review 1: "Long-term Outdoor Air Pollution and COVID-19 Mortality in London: an Individual-level Analysis"

Reviewers: Sophie M. Woodward, Xiao Wu |📒📒📒◻️◻️

Published onApr 25, 2023
Review 1: "Long-term Outdoor Air Pollution and COVID-19 Mortality in London: an Individual-level Analysis"


RR:C19 Evidence Scale rating by reviewer:

  • Potentially informative. The main claims made are not strongly justified by the methods and data, but may yield some insight. The results and conclusions of the study may resemble those from the hypothetical ideal study, but there is substantial room for doubt. Decision-makers should consider this evidence only with a thorough understanding of its weaknesses, alongside other evidence and theory. Decision-makers should not consider this actionable, unless the weaknesses are clearly understood and there is other theory and evidence to further support it.

***************************************

Review: The manuscript analyzes a large individual-level dataset to determine associations between long-term air pollution and COVID-19 mortality in London. An increased risk of dying from COVID-19 with increased exposure to air pollution was found when only adjusting for age, sex, and vaccination status in the regression model. Such a positive
association is not maintained after additionally adjusting for geographic factors (such as population density), ethnicity, and deprivation levels. Overall, the results seem potentially informative.

The strengths of this study derive from its large and representative population size (737,356 individuals who tested positive for COVID-19, including 9,315 COVID-19 related deaths), consideration of multiple pollutants, and comprehensive data linkage through the Office for National Statistics Public Health Data Asset (ONS-PHDA). The authors use Cox proportional hazard regression models to estimate the hazard ratios of dying from COVID-19 associated with increases in long-term (specifically, 2016 annual average) NO2, NOx, PM10, and PM2.5 concentrations separately. While adjusting only for age, sex, and vaccination status, the authors found a significant increased risk of COVID-19 mortality with increased air pollution exposure; but this association became non-significant when adjusting additionally for population density, rural/urban variables, ethnicity, adjusted household deprivation, and stratifying by local authority codes (the latter model is termed their ‘main model’).

Some aspects of this paper require further clarifications: First, the authors emphasize that after adjustment for ethnicity and deprivation the hazard ratios were reduced to unity, but this may be due to the sequential order of the models fit. The hazard ratios first became insignificant after geographic factors (population density, rural/urban variables, and local authority codes) were added to the model and remained insignificant when ethnicity and deprivation were subsequently added. The following hypothesis can not be ruled out: these geographic covariates capture most of the variation in air pollution, thus reducing the association of exposure and outcome to null when they are included in the model. While such a phenomenon is unlikely, it merits further discussion/exploration by the authors as to why controlling for these geographic covariates may influence the statistical results. Second, the confidence intervals of the hazard ratios become wider after accounting for geographic confounders. The discussion primarily focuses on ethnicity and deprivation as the culprits behind the null association, potentially overlooking other explanations of the findings. It can be helpful to see results from additional model fits in which ethnicity and deprivation are added to the base model without geographic confounders, as well as further description/definition of the local authority code, and analyses that add each geographic confounder to the base model one at a time.

A second limitation includes the temporal misalignment of the confounders: age, sex, ethnicity, adjusted household deprivation, and disability are sourced from the 2011 Census. If one hypothesis is that the deprivation serves as a major confounder, it would be important to obtain more recent data as the temporal changes in Census data may affect results.

A third limitation includes source and linkage of the exposure data. The authors use London Air Quality Network estimates of annual average air pollution concentration in 2016 as their exposure, suggesting that it could serve as a reasonable proxy for long-term exposure since spatial variability in air pollution across London has been relatively stable in recent years. As acknowledged in their discussion, other variables such as occupation and transport may affect an individual’s exposure.

A fourth limitation of this study is a lack of discussion on representativeness. Although the authors access a large, representative sample of medical records of London residents, only 54.1% of confirmed positive cases were linked to the ONS-PHDA, and it can be helpful if the authors could confirm that the reduced sample remains representative.

In conclusion, this work presents an interesting analysis of the association between long-term exposure to four air pollutants and risk of dying from COVID-19 using a comprehensive individual-level dataset. With some additional exploration and discussion, this manuscript has the potential to offer scientists and policy-makers valuable insights.

Comments
1
Vape Factory:

https://brooklyninc.ru/2022/12/26/elementor-12269/

https://ekids.edu.vn/brustschwimmen-muskelaufbau/

https://ekids.edu.vn/anabola-clenbuterol/

https://ekids.edu.vn/ejercicio-bosu/

https://ekids.edu.vn/aecn/

https://ekids.edu.vn/anabola-equipoise/

https://ekids.edu.vn/test-title6289/

https://ekids.edu.vn/test-title7170/

https://www.hurmio.fi/node/557668

https://www.hurmio.fi/node/557669

https://rcid.tums.ac.ir/?q=en/content/benefits-disposable-vaping-over-traditional-cigarettes

https://rcid.tums.ac.ir/?q=en/content/latest-innovations-disposable-vaping-technology

https://ysidhu.wixsite.com/website-1/forum/education-forum/how-to-use-a-vape

https://ysidhu.wixsite.com/website-1/forum/education-forum/vape-shape-and-atomizer-mechanism

https://www.smore.com/n60bj-how-to-use-a-vape

https://www.agentpet.com/forum/discussion/general/advantages-of-using-a-vape

https://forum.medmap.io/d/3356-advantages-of-using-a-vape

https://www.blockdit.com/posts/63e281eac0fd04717c87e45e

http://forum.gold-forum.ru/index.php?showtopic=59613

https://www.bitsdujour.com/view/advantages-of-using-a-vape

https://www.tickaroo.com/ticker/637f8657a720689dbb6849d5

https://fucksocial.net/events/721b0354-d587-4016-aed4-b64a5bf5fca5

https://typevape.splashthat.com/

https://gettogether.community/events/27412/vape-factory/

http://www.corrections.com/events/12022

https://eventregist.com/e/s8nIsLNzViWd

https://ticketbud.com/events/3f54ec5c-a39a-11ed-a537-42010a71701e

https://www.mixily.com/event/3676460065141150314

https://events.ydr.com/event/fc661db5a92ca57364a992b82e3c3896

https://events.ydr.com/event/cb9de660a4c8066a4f492db1e5a62d7c

https://d.io/vaperisk/afefd3

http://dom-nam.ru/index.php/forum/stroitelnye-kompanii/17886-what-is-the-healthiest-vape

http://dom-nam.ru/media/kunena/attachments/153139/Whatsthebestbrandofvape.pdf

https://vapecig.footeo.com/

https://vapecig.footeo.com/news/2022/11/24/types-of-vape

http://toparticlesubmissionsites.com/types-of-vape/

https://theomnibuzz.com/tips-to-quit-smoking-with-vape/

https://writeupcafe.com/the-vape-market-in-europe-and-the-u-s-and-europe/

https://articlepedia.xyz/can-i-sell-vapes-on-amazon/

https://randomarticle.xyz/how-do-i-quit-smoking-perfectly/

https://www.articlebowl.com/how-do-start-a-vape-business/

https://www.articleshood.com/how-to-find-a-reliable-vape-supplier/

https://www.articlefloor.com/how-to-start-a-vape-business-online/

https://www.articlequarter.com/the-top-5-vape-manufacturers/

https://www.articledistrict.com/what-is-the-best-way-to-start-a-vape-business/

https://www.articlewood.com/what-is-better-disposable-pods-or-vape/

https://www.peopleofarticle.com/are-there-any-benefits-of-switching-from-cigarettes-to-vaping/

https://www.articlemela.com/what-does-vaping-feel-like/

https://www.articleshore.com/can-you-buy-vape-devices-from-amazon/

https://www.articladihatti.com/the-risks-of-vaping-inside-a-casino/

https://www.articlescluster.com/is-it-safe-to-vape-with-no-nicotine/

https://articlezone.xyz/why-did-you-start-vaping/

https://articlezine.xyz/why-shouldnt-you-vape/

https://articlemag.xyz/should-i-start-vaping-if-i-m-a-smoker/

https://articleroom.xyz/should-i-start-vaping-if-i-m-a-smoker/

https://articlewrap.xyz/can-vaping-ever-be-safe/

https://articlepost.xyz/are-vape-devices-useful/

https://articlemania.xyz/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-disposable-vape/

https://dailybusinesspost.com/does-vaping-make-you-lose-weight/

https://dailybusinesspost.com/is-vaping-more-addictive-than-cigarette/

https://linkhay.com/link/5849728/vape-factory-from-china

https://linkhay.com/link/5849729/diposable-vapes

https://linkhay.com/u/vapecig

https://linkhay.com/blog/436082/features-and-benefits-of-e-cigarettes

https://flipboard.com/@VapeFactory

https://www.gapo.vn/1368661816

https://fr.quora.com/profile/Ecigator-New

https://vapecig.skyrock.com/

https://vapecig.skyrock.com/3352939636-How-to-choose-a-vape-manufacturer.html

https://www.sqworl.com/6aj0jg

https://www.strava.com/athletes/111060038/posts/22608893

https://www.cakeresume.com/matthew-ma

https://www.doyoubuzz.com/ma-matthew

https://diigo.com/0qto52

https://www.diigo.com/item/note/sb5u/skvt?k=0d91af8ef0c48dfe7f4fb3362f95dee3

https://fundrazr.com/profiles/ecigator-new

https://journal.thierry-pelle.eu/vapecig/vape-situation-in-indonesia

https://journal.thierry-pelle.eu/vapecig/

https://journal.thierry-pelle.eu/vapecig/whats-a-pod-vape

https://dribbble.com/shots/20002064-Armo-Bunny

https://www.bloggalot.com/lifestyle/do-e-cigarettes-help-you-quit-smoking

https://www.bloggalot.com/lifestyle/2-recommended-e-liquids

https://www.evernote.com/shard/s488/sh/209ad964-4871-0160-0e3a-8140ff7444e3/fdaacc077990b5718156a686043887d2

https://wise-atmosphere-86e.notion.site/Basic-knowledge-of-vape-83a033045ae94868a8c6db8e6e18bfa2

https://gotartwork.com/Blog/why-is-my-disposable-vape-pen-not-working/107257/

https://gotartwork.com/Blog/how-to-use-disposable-vape/107267/

https://click4r.com/posts/g/7525385/how-to-make-a-disposable-vape-hit-again

https://click4r.com/posts/g/7525703/how-to-make-disposable-vape-last-longer

https://www.kityfeed.com/hobbies/is-disposable-vape-safe.html

https://www.kityfeed.com/hobbies/are-disposable-vapes-safe.html

https://jobhop.co.uk/profile/184879

https://jobhop.co.uk/blog/184879

https://jobhop.co.uk/blog/184879/basic-knowledge-of-vape

http://jobhop.co.uk/company/ecigatorvape

https://onmogul.com/vapecig

https://onmogul.com/stories/basic-knowledge-of-vape

https://onmogul.com/stories/how-to-start-a-vape-business-in-2023

https://tbpchan.cz/biz/res/19.html

https://tbpchan.cz/biz/src/1669644398549.pdf

https://wakelet.com/@MatthewMa521

https://wakelet.com/wake/gTUjZ3eQ8dlEf66nu_kv3

https://www.storeboard.com/ecigatorvapewholesale

https://www.storeboard.com/blogs/health/tips-to-quit-smoking-with-vape/5544333

https://www.storeboard.com/blogs/health/are-disposable-vapes-cost-effective/5576342

https://www.thecityclassified.com/ads/vape-wholesale/

http://www.classtize.com/view/2-recommended-eliquids-1399682

https://freead1.net/ad/4019644/vape-wholesale.html

https://vatgia.com/raovat/9957/16968116/cach-chon-vape-dung-mot-lan.html

http://www.xcomplaints.com/complaint/vape-wholesale-c130226.html

https://vape.deno.dev/

https://melaninterest.com/user/vapecig/

https://xtibia.com/forum/topic/255532-what-is-a-vape/

https://pluginindia.freeforums.net/thread/2196/vape

https://pluginindia.freeforums.net/thread/2197/enjoy-vape-box

https://xtibia.com/forum/topic/255533-what-flavors-are-available-in-vape-liquids/

https://clubvapeadoresmexico.boards.net/thread/1381/ecigator-vape-wholesale-factory

https://clubvapeadoresmexico.boards.net/thread/1380/ecigator-sticky-prefilled-vape-starter

https://www.dagaldan.co.il/forum/general-discussion/what-is-a-vape

https://www.padelforum.org/threads/how-to-choose-the-right-battery-to-enjoy-vaping.115707/

https://civilqa.com/en/how-to-choose-a-vape-battery/

https://www.mastersindia.co/q/question/how-to-choose-a-vape-battery/

https://www.zupyak.com/p/3377746/t/lets-get-the-basics-of-vape

https://www.zupyak.com/p/3377749/t/vape-wholesale-directly-from-china-vape-factory

https://community.gtarcade.com/thread/1388232-1-1.html

https://www.truxgo.net/blogs/391817/1201180/how-to-choose-an-e-cigarette

https://www.truxgo.net/blogs/391817/1201185/what-is-a-vape

https://www.truxgo.net/blogs/391817/1201187/i-want-to-enjoy-vape-in-a-box

https://bloggalot.com/lifestyle/2-recommended-e-liquids

https://bloggalot.com/lifestyle/do-e-cigarettes-help-you-quit-smoking

https://bloggalot.com/lifestyle/how-to-choose-the-right-battery-to-enjoy-vaping

https://dailygram.com/blog/1177995/what-is-vitamin-e-cigarette/

https://dailygram.com/blog/1177996/points-to-consider-when-choosing-a-vitamin-e-cigarette/

https://dailygram.com/blog/1186153/why-should-i-choose-a-disposable-vape-pen/

https://dailygram.com/blog/1198149/how-to-get-the-most-out-of-your-disposable-vaping-device/

https://webyourself.eu/vapecig

https://webyourself.eu/posts/53387

https://webyourself.eu/pages/vapecig

https://webyourself.eu/blogs/53389/What-is-vitamin-e-cigarette

https://webyourself.eu/blogs/53390/Points-to-consider-when-choosing-a-vitamin-e-cigarette

https://webyourself.eu/blogs/53391/What-vapde-devices-do-you-recommend

https://geto.space/vapecig

https://geto.space/vaporecig

https://geto.space/read-blog/88780

https://geto.space/read-blog/88781

https://geto.space/read-blog/88782

https://www.ethiovisit.com/myplace/posts/158254

https://www.ethiovisit.com/myplace/vapecig

https://www.ethiovisit.com/myplace/pages/vapecignew

https://www.promorapid.com/6352a2417

https://www.promorapid.com/post/568061_ecigator-is-one-of-the-well-known-vape-brands-spun-off-from-giftsoar-technology.html

https://www.sachamberrapidresponse.org/forum/general-discussions/the-pros-and-cons-of-using-disposable-vapes

https://www.blogulr.com/vapecig/convenient-and-cost-effective-disposable-vapes-explained-72277

https://www.blogulr.com/vapecig/discover-the-convenience-of-disposable-vape-72279

https://www.pickmemo.com/vapecig

https://www.pickmemo.com/post/197402_ecigator-is-one-of-the-well-known-vape-brands-spun-off-from-giftsoar-technology.html

https://www.pickmemo.com/read-blog/126285

https://www.pickmemo.com/read-blog/126286

https://www.pickmemo.com/read-blog/126287

https://www.social-vape.com/1676813311955772_10839

https://www.social-vape.com/post/49369_ecigator-is-one-of-the-well-known-vape-brands-spun-off-from-giftsoar-technology.html

https://www.social-vape.com/read-blog/21617

https://www.social-vape.com/read-blog/21618

https://www.social-vape.com/read-blog/21620

https://frustratedgamers.com/vapenew

https://frustratedgamers.com/post/315499_ecigator-is-one-of-the-well-known-vape-brands-spun-off-from-giftsoar-technology.html

https://frustratedgamers.com/read-blog/250741

https://frustratedgamers.com/read-blog/250743

https://frustratedgamers.com/read-blog/250744

https://bresdel.com/vapecig

https://bresdel.com/posts/273285

https://bresdel.com/pages/ecignew

https://bresdel.com/blogs/273287/What-is-vitamin-e-cigarette

https://bresdel.com/blogs/273288/Points-to-consider-when-choosing-a-vitamin-e-cigarette

https://bresdel.com/blogs/273289/What-vapde-devices-do-you-recommend

https://kyourc.com/vapecig

https://kyourc.com/post/59288_ecigator-is-one-of-the-well-known-vape-brands-spun-off-from-giftsoar-technology.html

https://kyourc.com/read-blog/59682

https://kyourc.com/read-blog/59683

https://kyourc.com/read-blog/59684

https://www.trackthattravel.com/travelblog/39963

https://www.trackthattravel.com/travelblog/39966

https://www.trackthattravel.com/travelblog/39969

https://naijacontacts.com/topics/view/94584

https://naijacontacts.com/topics/view/95636

https://hackmd.io/@vapecig/r1nAz_8wo

https://hackmd.io/@vapecig/HyU7X_Ivs

https://hackmd.io/@vapecig/HJ8HQ_LDs

https://getinkspired.com/en/story/297724/pod-type-vape-is-a-hot-item/

https://git.guildofwriters.org/DoobesURU/moul-assets-doobes/issues/336

https://i2pgit.org/Vapecig/vape

https://vapelife.unicornplatform.page/

http://vapelife.rf.gd/

http://vape123.42web.io/

http://nicevape.great-site.net/

https://www.gocrowdera.com/campaign/where-can-i-purchase-pod-type-vape

https://sajhi.com/vapecig

https://sajhi.com/posts/49503

https://sajhi.com/posts/49504

https://sajhi.com/blogs/49505/Where-can-I-purchase-POD-type-vape

https://sajhi.com/blogs/49506/POD-type-vape-is-a-hot-item

https://sajhi.com/blogs/49507/What-vapde-devices-do-you-recommend

https://www.bonfire.com/vape-factory/

http://nigerianwiki.com/User:Vapefactory

https://shortest.activeboard.com/forum.spark?aBID=160356&p=83&topicID=68983403&commentID=68983403

https://bigcitydreamz.com/blog/how-do-you-use-a-pod-vape

https://bigcitydreamz.com/blog/vapde-devices-recommend

https://paperpage.in/vapecig

https://paperpage.in/posts/2219

https://paperpage.in/blogs/2222/What-is-electronic-cigarette-and-the-type

https://paperpage.in/blogs/2223/Advantages-of-Vaping-to-Quit-Smoking

https://www.gamerlaunch.com/community/users/blog/6273360/?mode=view&gid=535

https://www.party.biz/profile/vapecig

https://www.party.biz/blogs/144469/187303/what-is-plume-tech

https://mcspartners.ning.com/forum/topics/what-are-the-various-types-and-varieties

https://mcspartners.ning.com/photo/albums/vape-factory

https://www.onfeetnation.com/profiles/blogs/what-is-the-cheapest-way-to-vape

https://www.onfeetnation.com/profiles/blogs/what-websites-sell-vapes-without-id

https://www.onfeetnation.com/profiles/blogs/can-you-legally-ship-a-vape

https://www.esurveyspro.com/Survey.aspx?id=e31f8b4c-06a4-434b-96d8-afcbcea7a387

https://questionpro.com/t/AXQY1Zwvy6

https://dopostings.com/5-disposable-vapes-recommended/

https://dopostings.com/author/vapecig/

https://peatix.com/group/11911636/view

https://peatix.com/event/3438786/view

https://www.tipga.com/e/63930af33286fe44e333dab7

https://www.liveinternet.ru/users/vapelife/

https://www.liveinternet.ru/users/vapelife/post496870078/

https://www.liveinternet.ru/users/vapelife/post496870207/

https://jemi.so/vapecig

https://jemi.so/vapecig/blog

https://www.loom.com/share/7407cbe13dfe4daa82f161c9dcc0aef3

https://note.com/vapecig/n/n95210e1b965f

https://vocus.cc/article/63df9c71fd89780001447e14

https://cafe.cfma.org/viewdocument/some-popular-e-cigarette-recommenda

https://www.arkbar.com/network/members/profile?UserKey=11424fed-d020-4c03-96c1-018511c77d35

https://www.common.org/network/members/profile?UserKey=7102028f-c7ed-4250-ae23-c42daba08162

https://community.arubainstanton.com/network/members/profile?UserKey=c1e39f78-fa78-4ea8-a188-837b96cd76ea

https://collaborate.amcp.org/network/members/profile?UserKey=256bca7b-ffa6-4d91-ae05-2936c359e53c

https://community.acsi.org/network/members/profile?UserKey=e3e04907-bcba-4707-a2d0-77c3f15cf7b2

https://community.acec.org/network/members/profile?UserKey=467a789c-74f4-49d5-8f84-c126b1282f8d

https://raindrop.io/vapelife/disposable-vape-29809666

https://web.ggather.com/vapecig

https://www.lasso.net/go/link/eWZoBK

https://disposablevape.notion.site/

https://www.clipix.com/9/share-4iaxQ-Dm

https://vapelife-f911a.web.app/

https://storage.googleapis.com/podvape/index.html

https://t.me/s/dispovape

https://discussions.apple.com/thread/254471492

https://vapelife.mobirisesite.com/

https://vapecig.take.app/

https://phs.vn/faqDetail?id=3145

https://phs.vn/faqDetail?id=3146

https://vapecig-disposablevape.pbworks.com/w/file/152285106/What%27s%20the%20best%20brand%20of%20vape.pdf