Skip to main content
SearchLoginLogin or Signup

Review 2: "Four Stylized Facts about COVID-19"

Reviewers find that this paper raises important questions about overstating the importance of government-mandated non-pharmaceutical interventions, but that it is undermined by unclear inclusion criteria and overly-broad conclusions that are not all supported by the evidence.

Published onFeb 07, 2021
Review 2: "Four Stylized Facts about COVID-19"
1 of 2
key-enterThis Pub is a Review of
Four Stylized Facts about COVID-19

RR:C19 Evidence Scale rating by reviewer:

  • Potentially informative. The main claims made are not strongly justified by the methods and data, but may yield some insight. The results and conclusions of the study may resemble those from the hypothetical ideal study, but there is substantial room for doubt. Decision-makers should consider this evidence only with a thorough understanding of its weaknesses, alongside other evidence and theory. Decision-makers should not consider this actionable unless the weaknesses are clearly understood and there is other theory and evidence to further support it.

***************************************

Review:

“Four Stylized Facts About COVID-19” analyzes the cross-country dynamics of the evolution of the COVID-19 epidemic, focusing in particular on the growth rate of daily COVID-19 deaths. It finds that, in all countries and regions considered, such growth rates (i) fell to zero within the 30 days following the record of the 25th cumulative death, and (ii) hovered around zero or below thereafter. The authors then use these findings to conclude that there exists a yet-to-be understood factor that naturally pushes the reproduction rate of COVID-19 downwards. They also argue that empirical studies analyzing the effects of government-mandated non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) may overstate their effectiveness if they fail to account for this factor.

Although the authors employ sophisticated methods, I believe that the authors’ findings are not sufficient to substantially justify the claims they make regarding the reliability of empirical studies analyzing the effectiveness of NPIs. I organize my review around two main points.

1. Country sample and authors findings: the authors claim that they select all countries and U.S. states that had recorded at least 1,000 COVID-19 deaths by late July 2020 to carry out their study. The criteria used to select the countries covered seems arbitrary as it excludes small countries. Choosing a per capita deaths threshold would have been more appropriate. But this is not my main concern. Following their criteria, the authors select 23 countries and 25 U.S. states. I have followed COVID-19 news myself and reading that only 24 countries had recorded more than 1,000 deaths by late July 2020 felt odd. To verify this, I sourced daily data on COVID-19 deaths in all countries of the world from the dataset of the European Centre for Diseases Prevention and Control. The countries that had experienced at least 1,000 deaths by the end of July are almost twice as many (42) as the 24 selected by the authors.

I then calculated the growth rate of daily COVID-19 deaths since the 25th cumulative death for the countries that should be in the sample but are not included and found that for many it did not fall to 0 within the first 30 days from the 25th cumulative death nor it did hover at or below 0 after that. Figure 1 below depicts the growth rate of COVID-19 deaths in important countries such as Bolivia, Colombia, Indonesia, and South Africa, which the authors do not include in their study. For none of these countries, the growth rate of daily deaths stabilized at or below zero at any point in the period considered. I believe that the main findings of the authors would not be the same had they picked a more representative sample.


2. Authors conclusions from their findings: the authors conclude that, since all the countries that they considered experienced a decline in the growth rate of COVID-19 deaths, there must exist an intrinsic factor that naturally pushes downwards the reproduction rate of COVID-19 and that not accounting for this factor risks overstating the effectiveness of government-mandated NPIs in reducing the spread of COVID-19.

In my view, the fact that many (not all) countries experienced a decline in the COVID-19 reproduction rate is not enough to claim that there must exist a yet-to-be-understood factor that naturally pushes the rate of COVID-19 infections down. Most governments around the world (even in Sweden, which the authors often cite as an example of laissez-faire) have adopted some measures to reduce the number of COVID-19 infections. It is precisely these measures that may well have put downward pressures on the reproduction rate of COVID-19. Ignoring the intensity of government interventions to reduce infections and claiming that the downward pressure in the reproduction rate is the result of some other unobserved factor seems counterintuitive to me.

The authors also observe that the relaxation of NPIs in many countries over the summer of 2020 did not lead to another immediate surge of COVID-19 infections and deaths. The authors wrote their paper in August 2020. I believe that, had they waited a bit longer, they would not have made the same claim. Indeed, many countries that relaxed NPIs in the summer months experienced a surge in infections in the fall.

Since there is considerable variation in the intensity of government-mandated NPIs, a good way to analyze whether NPIs have any effect on COVID-19 reproduction rate is to check whether countries/regions in which the intensity of NPIs is higher have experienced faster declines. I myself have conducted one such analysis exploiting exogenous variation across local labor markets in the tightness of the government-mandated national lockdown in Italy and came to a very different conclusion from that of the authors (see Ciminelli and Garcia- Mandicó, 2020).

REFERENCES

Ciminelli, Gabriele and Garcia-Mandico, Silvia, Business Shutdowns and COVID-19 Mortality (2020). Available at SSRN: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3683324

Comments
14
?
Lamba Lol:

The review highlights significant flaws in the paper, particularly the arbitrary sample selection and unsupported conclusions about an unobserved factor reducing COVID-19 reproduction rates. It emphasizes that the authors undervalue the role of government NPIs and rely on incomplete data, weakening their claims.
For Covid 19 Grants info visit: what is sassa
sassa appeal
SRD grant in Covid 19
SRD payment dates
appeal status check
sassa status

?
jewellery store in UK:

Vape Universe is a leading provider of high-quality vape wholesale los angeles vape products, offering exceptional vape wholesale services in Los Angeles. Whether you are a retailer looking to stock your shelves or a business seeking bulk orders, Vape Universe has you covered with a vast selection of top-tier vapes, accessories, and e-liquids. As a trusted name in the vape industry, Vape Universe ensures competitive prices, reliable delivery, and a commitment to customer satisfaction. For businesses in Los Angeles, Vape Universe is the go-to source for all your vape wholesale needs, delivering quality products and outstanding service every time.

?
jewellery store in UK:

サッカーの未来を描く話題作、ブルーロック Raw 285がついに公開されました!この最新章では、プレイヤーたちが新たな戦術やスキルを駆使し、熾烈な戦いがさらに白熱します。チーム間の競争、個々の成長、そして驚きの展開が読者を引き込むこと間違いなしです。進化し続ける物語の核心を見逃さないよう、ぜひこちらでブルーロック Raw 285をチェックしてください!

?
Michal Jordan:

GBWhatsApp is a modified version of the official WhatsApp, offering additional features like customization options, enhanced privacy settings, and the ability to use multiple accounts on a single device

?
Lamba Lol:

If you’re searching for a better TikTok video downloader, this one’s a game-changer! It’s super fast, keeps the quality high, and best of all—no watermarks. Just copy the link, paste it here, and download your favorite TikToks in seconds. Definitely my top choice for smooth, reliable video downloads!

?
Lamba Lol:

The planet’s order in Snapchat’s friend’s circle is such a cool way to visualize friendships! Each friend has a unique planet position in your 'solar system,' reflecting how close you are based on interactions. The closer the planet to the 'sun,' the stronger your bond with that friend. It’s like Snapchat’s own friendship universe where you can see who’s in your inner orbit!

?
kaya amari:

This review of the COVID-19 study touches on the importance of properly assessing and verifying data when drawing significant conclusions, particularly in contexts where policies impact public health. It reminds me of how crucial proper identity verification is when managing social welfare systems, such as SASSA in South Africa. Just as this study could benefit from more accurate data selection and sample representation, SASSA relies on thorough identity verification SASSA processes to ensure that beneficiaries receive the right support. A system that overlooks key factors or fails to account for the proper data risks harming those most in need—be it in healthcare or social welfare.

?
anderson jerry:

Hungry Shark Mod APK offers an enhanced gaming experience for fans of the popular underwater adventure game, Hungry Shark World. With this mod, players can unlock premium features, unlimited coins, and gems, making it easier to upgrade sharks, complete missions, and dominate the ocean. The mod APK removes the usual in-game restrictions, allowing players to explore vast oceanic landscapes, hunt prey, and battle enemies without worrying about limited resources. Whether you're a casual gamer or a competitive player, the Hungry Shark Mod APK provides an exciting, action-packed experience that keeps the adventure going strong.

?
anderson jerry:

If your SASSA declined appeal has left you uncertain about your next steps, it’s important to understand the reasons behind it and how to resolve the issue. The South African Social Security Agency (SASSA) provides a crucial financial safety net for those in need, but there are instances where appeals for grants get declined. Whether it’s due to incomplete documentation, missing eligibility criteria, or system errors, knowing how to navigate the process can make a significant difference. Learn more about addressing a SASSA declined appeal by visiting SASSA Appeals for further guidance and updates.

?
ali hassan:

The reviewer raises valid concerns about the sample selection and conclusions in the "Four Stylized Facts About COVID-19" paper. Excluding many relevant countries undermines the study’s claims, and the assumption of an unobserved factor reducing COVID-19 reproduction rates neglects the role of government interventions. A more comprehensive analysis, factoring in variations in NPIs, is needed to support the conclusions more effectively. Remini Apk for PC/Mac

Ali Hassan:

The reviewer raises valid concerns about the sample selection and conclusions in the "Four Stylized Facts About COVID-19" paper. The exclusion of many relevant countries weakens the study's claims, and the assumption of an unobserved factor lowering COVID-19 reproduction rates overlooks the impact of government interventions. A more robust analysis, considering variations in NPIs and possibly update your SASSA banking details, is necessary to substantiate the conclusions.

?
sasafg hsea:

Beneficiaries can confirm whether their grant payments have been processed and when they can expect to receive them https://srdsassagov.co.za/. This is essential for planning and managing household budgets.


will james:

Introduce innovative technologies like IoT and AI to modernize agriculture. Offer solutions for precision farming, crop monitoring, and yield optimization. Farmers, agricultural businesses, and technology enthusiasts.

pop over to these guys

my site

dig this

?
Stock svv:

So, if you're looking to explore the world of digital currencies and earn rewards in the process, Faucetspoint is the platform for you. Start earning today and discover the exciting potential of cryptocurrencies! https://faucetspoint.com/